IRS Publishes Temporary and Proposed Regs on Corporate Tax Shelter Registration

The temporary regs define what it is for a corporation to have a significant purpose of federal tax avoidance under section 6111(d)(1)(A) (not section 6662(d)(2)(C)(iii)). First, a customer has a significant purpose of tax avoidance if the transaction is listed in published guidance as required to be registered, or otherwise identified in guidance as a tax avoidance transaction. (For a list of transactions that must be reported and registered, see Notice 2000-15, Doc 2000-5712 (3 original pages).) Second, there is a significant purpose of tax avoidance if the transaction would not pass the economic substance test used in Notice 98-5, 1998-3 IRB 49. That test asks whether the reasonably expected pre-tax profit (determined on a present value basis) is insignificant relative to the reasonably expected net tax benefits. (For a summary of Notice 98-5, see Tax Notes, Dec. 29, 1997, p. 1451; for the full text, see Doc 98-175 (16 pages), 97 TNT 247-3 , or H&D, Dec. 24, 1997, p. 3798.)

Third, a significant purpose of tax avoidance is present if tax benefits are an important intended result of the deal, and the promoter expects to market the deal to more than one potential customer. There is no significant purpose of tax avoidance for transactions that the promoter thinks are part of the ordinary course of the customer's business, consistent with customary commercial practice, and for which there is a longstanding and generally accepted understanding of the expected tax treatment. Fourth, promoters may argue that there is no reasonable basis under the federal tax law for denial of the expected tax benefits. Promoters also may ask for rulings whether their transactions must be registered.

The temporary regulations also elaborate on the section 6111(d)(2) definition of conditions of confidentiality. The regs further describe when the $100,000 statutory fee threshold is met.

Registration, on a revised Form 8264, requires the promoter to provide a detailed description of the shelter, as well as marketing materials with the registration form. A shelter cannot be broken into its component transactions; all the steps of the same deal required to be carried out by the same customer have to be described on the same form. Lawyers acting as promoters who take the view that their tax shelter advice is privileged may omit arguably privileged material and attach a statement to that effect to the registration form. If the tax shelter promoter is foreign, then the customer or potential customer, including a foreign corporation that owes U.S. tax, must register the shelter.

T.D. 8876 is effective February 28, 2000.

This document appeared in TNT as 2000 TNT 40-16 and in the AccServ & Microfiche as Doc 2000-5716 (37 original pages).

[2] ACTION: Temporary regulations.

[3] SUMMARY: This document contains temporary regulations requiring the registration of confidential corporate tax shelters pursuant to section 6111(d) as amended by section 1028(a) of the Taxpayer Relief Act of 1997 (the Act). The temporary regulations affect persons responsible for registering confidential corporate tax shelters. The text of these temporary regulations also serves as the text of the proposed regulations set forth in the notice of proposed rulemaking on this subject in REG-110311-98 published elsewhere in this issue of the Federal Register.

[4] DATES: Effective date. These temporary regulations are effective February 28, 2000.

[5] Applicability date. For dates of applicability, see section 301.6111-2T(h) of these regulations.

[6] FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Richard Castanon, (202) 622-3080, or Mary Beth Collins, (202) 622-3070; concerning international issues Rebecca Rosenberg, (202) 622-3870 (not toll-free numbers).

[7] SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

Paperwork Reduction Act

[8] These regulations are being issued without prior notice and public procedure pursuant to the Administrative Procedure Act (5 U.S.C. 553). For this reason, the collections of information contained in these regulations have been reviewed and, pending receipt and evaluation of public comments, approved by the Office of Management and Budget under control number 1545-1687. Responses to these collections of information are mandatory.

[9] An agency may not conduct or sponsor, and a person is not required to respond to, a collection of information unless the collection of information displays a valid OMB control number.

[10] For further information concerning these collections of information, and where to submit comments on the collections of information and the accuracy of the estimated burden, and suggestions for reducing this burden, please refer to the preamble to the cross- referencing notice of proposed rulemaking published in the Proposed Rules section of this issue of the Federal Register.

[11] Books or records relating to a collection of information must be retained as long as their contents may become material in the administration of any internal revenue law. Generally, tax returns and tax return information are confidential, as required by 26 U.S.C. 6103.

Background

[12] In enacting section 6111(d), Congress added confidential corporate tax shelters as a type of tax shelter that must be registered under section 6111. Congress intended the provision to improve tax compliance by giving the Treasury Department earlier notification of transactions that may not comport with Federal tax law and by discouraging taxpayers from entering into questionable transactions. See H.R. REP. NO. 148, 105th Cong., 1st Sess. 469 (1997); S. REP. NO. 33, 105th Cong., 1st Sess. 148 (1997).

[13] Section 1028(e)(1) of the Act provides that the registration requirements of section 6111 and the penalty provisions of section 6707 for failing to comply with the registration requirements apply to confidential corporate tax shelters in which interests are offered to potential participants after the IRS issues guidance on the registration requirements. These regulations provide the guidance necessary to activate the registration requirements of section 6111 and the penalty provisions of section 6707 for confidential corporate tax shelters.

[14] These temporary regulations relate to disclosure obligations for tax shelter organizers and promoters under section 6111. Although the terms of section 6111(d)(1)(A), which are part of the definition of a confidential corporate tax shelter, are similar to the definition of tax shelter under section 6662(d)(2)(C)(iii), these temporary regulations are not intended to define a tax shelter for purposes of section 6662, which relates to the imposition of penalties.

Explanation of Provisions

I. In General

[15] Under section 6111(d)(1) and the temporary regulations, a confidential corporate tax shelter is any entity, plan, arrangement, or transaction that satisfies the following three requirements: (1) a significant purpose of the structure of the transaction is the avoidance or evasion of Federal income tax for a direct or an indirect corporate participant; (2) the transaction is offered to any potential participant under conditions of confidentiality; and (3) the tax shelter promoters may receive fees in excess of $100,000 in the aggregate.

II. Significant Purpose of Tax Avoidance or Tax Evasion

[16] Under the temporary regulations, there are three categories of transactions for which the avoidance or evasion of Federal income tax is considered a significant purpose of the structure of the transaction.

[17] First, the avoidance or evasion of Federal income tax is considered a significant purpose of the structure of a transaction if the transaction is the same as or substantially similar to one of the specified types of transactions that the IRS has determined to be a tax avoidance transaction and identified by notice, regulation, or other form of published guidance as a listed transaction for purposes of section 6111.

[18] Second, the avoidance or evasion of Federal income tax is generally considered a significant purpose of the structure of a transaction if the present value of the participant's reasonably expected pre-tax profit (after taking into account foreign taxes as expenses and transaction costs) from the transaction is insignificant relative to the present value of the participant's expected net Federal income tax savings from the transaction. However, if the substance of the transaction is the borrowing of money or the acquisition of financial capital by a corporate participant, the transaction falls within this second category if the present value of the Federal income tax deductions of the taxpayer to whom the loan or financial capital is provided significantly exceeds the present value of the pre-tax return of the person providing the loan or financial capital.

[19] Third, the avoidance or evasion of Federal income tax is generally considered to be a significant purpose of the structure of a transaction if the transaction has been structured to produce Federal income tax benefits that constitute an important part of the intended results of the transaction and the tax shelter promoter (or other person who would be responsible for registration under this section) reasonably expects the transaction to be presented (in the same or substantially similar form) to more than one potential participant. However, a transaction does not come within this third category if the promoter reasonably determines that the potential participant is expected to participate in the transaction in the ordinary course of its business in a form consistent with customary commercial practice, and the promoter reasonably determines that there is a long-standing and generally accepted understanding that the expected Federal income tax benefits from the transaction (taking into account any combination of intended tax consequences) are allowable under the Code for substantially similar transactions.

[20] Except for listed transactions, the avoidance or evasion of Federal income tax will not be considered a significant purpose of the structure of a transaction if the tax shelter promoter (or other person who would be responsible for registration under this section) reasonably determines that there is no reasonable basis under Federal tax law for denial of any significant portion of the expected Federal income tax benefits from the transaction.

[21] The IRS may make a determination, by published guidance, individual ruling, or otherwise, that a transaction is not required to be registered under the temporary regulations. If a tax shelter promoter (or other person who would be responsible for registration under this section) is uncertain whether a transaction is properly classified as a confidential corporate tax shelter or is otherwise uncertain whether registration is required under this section, that person may, on or before the date that registration would otherwise be required under this section, submit a request to the IRS for a ruling as to whether the transaction is subject to the registration requirements of this section. If the request fully discloses all relevant facts relating to the transaction, that person's potential obligation to register the transaction will be suspended during the period that the ruling request is pending and, if the Service subsequently concludes that the transaction is a confidential corporate tax shelter subject to registration under this section, until the sixtieth day after the issuance of the ruling (or, if the request is withdrawn, sixty days from the date that the request is withdrawn). In the alternative, that person may register the transaction in accordance with the requirements of this section and append a statement to the Form 8264, "Application for Registration of a Tax Shelter," which states that the person is uncertain whether the transaction is required to be registered as a confidential corporate tax shelter, and that the Form 8264 is being filed on a protective basis.

III. Conditions of Confidentiality

[22] Section 6111(d)(2) describes when an offer is made under conditions of confidentiality. The determination of whether an offer is made under conditions of confidentiality is based on all the facts and circumstances surrounding the offer, including prior conduct of the parties. If an offeree's disclosure of the structure or tax aspects of the transaction is limited in any way by an express or implied understanding or agreement with or for the benefit of a tax shelter promoter, an offer is considered made under conditions of confidentiality, whether or not such understanding or agreement is legally binding. An offer will also be considered made under conditions of confidentiality in the absence of any such understanding or agreement if any tax shelter promoter knows or has reason to know the transaction is protected from disclosure or use in any other manner, such as where the transaction is claimed to be proprietary to the tax shelter promoter or any party other than the offeree. An offeree's privilege to maintain the confidentiality of a communication relating to a tax shelter in which the taxpayer might participate or has agreed to participate, including an offeree's confidential communication with the offeree's attorney, is not itself a condition of confidentiality.

[23] The temporary regulations provide that, unless facts and circumstances clearly indicate otherwise, an offer is not considered made under conditions of confidentiality if the tax shelter promoter enters into a written agreement with each person who participates or discusses participation in the transaction and such agreement expressly authorizes such persons to disclose every aspect of the transaction to any and all persons, without limitation of any kind.

IV. Fees

[24] The third requirement that must be satisfied for a transaction to be treated as a confidential corporate tax shelter is that the tax shelter promoters, whether or not related, may receive fees in excess of $100,000 in the aggregate. In determining whether the tax shelter promoters may receive fees in excess of $100,000, all the facts and circumstances surrounding the transaction are considered. For this purpose, all consideration that may be received by the tax shelter promoters is taken into account, including contingent fees, fees in the form of equity interests, and fees the promoters may receive for other transactions as consideration for promoting the tax shelter.

[25] For example, if a tax shelter promoter may receive a fee for arranging a transaction that is a confidential corporate tax shelter and/or a separate fee for another transaction that is not a confidential corporate tax shelter, part or all of the fee paid with respect to the other transaction may be treated as a fee paid with respect to the confidential corporate tax shelter if the facts and circumstances indicate that the fee paid for the other transaction is in consideration for the confidential corporate tax shelter. For purposes of determining whether the tax shelter promoters may receive fees in excess of $100,000, the fees from all substantially similar transactions are considered part of the same tax shelter and must be aggregated.

V. Registration Requirements

[26] To register a confidential corporate tax shelter, the person responsible for registering the tax shelter must file Form 8264, "Application for Registration of a Tax Shelter." (Form 8264 is also used to register tax shelters defined in section 6111(c).) The exemptions from the registration requirements contained in the instructions to the current Form 8264 apply only to tax shelters defined in section 6111(c). Form 8264 will be revised and will include specific requirements and instructions for registering confidential corporate tax shelters. Until that time, persons responsible for registering confidential corporate tax shelters should follow the registration procedures outlined in these regulations.

[27] The temporary regulations provide that the person registering a confidential corporate tax shelter must provide a detailed description of the tax shelter, including the structure of the tax shelter and the tax benefits. Any written materials presented in connection with an offer to participate in the shelter are required to be submitted with the registration form.

[28] Consistent with the registration requirements for tax shelters defined in section 6111(c), the temporary regulations provide that any transactions involving similar business assets or similar plans or arrangements that are offered to corporate taxpayers by the same person or by related persons are aggregated and treated as a single tax shelter. However, in contrast with the registration requirements applicable to tax shelters defined in section 6111(c), the temporary regulations allow the tax shelter promoter to file a single Form 8264 with respect to any such aggregated tax shelter, provided an amended Form 8264 is filed to reflect any material changes and to include any additional or revised written materials presented in connection with an offer to participate in the shelter. Furthermore, the temporary regulations require all transactions that are part of the same tax shelter and that are to be carried out by the same corporate participant (or one or more other members of the same affiliated group within the meaning of section 1504) to be registered on the same Form 8264.

[29] The temporary regulations provide that in cases in which an attorney or federally authorized tax practitioner acts as a tax shelter promoter with respect to a client's participation in a confidential corporate tax shelter and believes that information which would otherwise be required to be disclosed on Form 8264 is protected by the common law attorney-client privilege or the confidentiality privilege under section 7525(a), such promoter may omit the information believed to be privileged from Form 8264 if the promoter attaches a statement to the Form 8264 as described in these temporary regulations.

[30] Section 6111(a)(1) requires a tax shelter to be registered not later than the day on which the first offering for sale of interests in such shelter occurs. Section 6111(d)(4) provides that an offer to participate in a confidential corporate tax shelter shall be treated as an offer for sale.

[31] Registration under these temporary regulations will be limited to confidential corporate tax shelters that are offered for sale after February 28, 2000. If interests in a confidential corporate tax shelter were first offered for sale on or before February 28, 2000, the first offer for sale of interests in the shelter that occurs after February 28, 2000, shall be considered the first offer for sale under this section. The temporary regulations provide that the IRS will consider a registration as timely made for a confidential corporate tax shelter in which interests are offered for sale after February 28, 2000, if the confidential corporate tax shelter is registered no later than August 26, 2000.

[32] If a transaction becomes a confidential corporate tax shelter (e.g., because of a change in the law or factual circumstances, or because the transaction becomes a listed transaction) subsequent to the first offering for sale after February 28, 2000, and the transaction was not previously required to be registered as a confidential corporate tax shelter under this section, the transaction must be registered under this section if interests are offered for sale after the transaction becomes a confidential corporate tax shelter. The transaction must be registered by the later of the next offering for sale of interests in the shelter or August 26, 2000. However, because transactions identified as listed transactions are generally considered to have been structured for a significant tax avoidance purpose, such transactions ordinarily will have been subject to registration under this section before becoming listed transactions.

[33] The temporary regulations provide that if an interest in a confidential corporate tax shelter is first offered for sale after February 28, 2000, and that shelter is also a tax shelter under section 6111(c), the person responsible for registering the shelter may either (1) complete and file Form 8264, including the information required by these temporary regulations for confidential corporate tax shelters, not later than the day on which an interest in the shelter is first offered for sale after February 28, 2000, or (2) complete and file Form 8264 for the section 6111(c) tax shelter not later than the day on which an interest in the tax shelter is first offered for sale under section 6111(a) and then file an amended Form 8264 with the information required by these temporary regulations not later than August 26, 2000.

VI. Tax Shelter Promoter and Person Required to Register

[34] The temporary regulations provide that the term "tax shelter promoter" as described in section 6111(d)(2) includes a tax shelter organizer under section 6111(e)(1) and section 301.6111- 1T(Q&A-26 through Q&A-32) and any other person who participates in the organization, management or sale of a tax shelter (other than a person who merely performs services of the kind described in Q&A-33 of section 301.6111-1T) or any person related (within the meaning of section 267 or 707) to such tax shelter organizer or such other person.

[35] In addition to the registration rules in section 6111, the rules in section 301.6111-1T(Q&A-34 through Q&A-39) apply for determining who must register a confidential corporate tax shelter.

[36] The temporary regulations specify that, if all of the tax shelter promoters of a confidential corporate tax shelter are foreign persons and none of such promoters registers the shelter, any person who discusses participation in the shelter must register the shelter under section 6111(a). Pursuant to the authority in section 6111(f)(4), under limited circumstances, the temporary regulations apply to foreign as well as United States persons. For example, a foreign corporation that participates in a tax shelter with a significant purpose of reducing its United States taxes would be required to register the tax shelter if there were no U.S. promoters and the other requirements of the temporary regulations were satisfied.

[37] Under the temporary regulations, if all the tax shelter promoters of a confidential corporate tax shelter are foreign persons, any person who discusses participation in the confidential corporate tax shelter with a tax shelter promoter must register the shelter within 90 days of beginning such discussions unless one or more of the following occurs: (1) the person does not participate in the shelter and notifies the promoter in writing, within the 90-day period, that the person will not participate; or (2) within the 90- day period, the person obtains and reasonably relies on both a written statement from one of the tax shelter promoters that such promoter has registered the tax shelter under this section and a copy of the registration.

[38] To prevent avoidance of the purposes of section 6111(d)(3), the temporary regulations treat any person that participates in a shelter as having discussed that participation. Such discussion will be treated as occurring on the date of the agreement to participate or, if earlier, any other date the person is treated as having discussed participation under any other provision of these regulations. Thus, the participant is treated as having discussed participation in the shelter even if the agreement to participate is made without direct discussions by the participant. This might occur, for example, if participation is agreed to through an intermediary acting on the participant's behalf.

[39] The temporary regulations also state that a person (first person) will be treated as participating indirectly in (and therefore as discussing) a tax shelter if a foreign person in which the first person has at least a 10 percent interest participates in the shelter with a significant purpose of avoiding or evading the first person's Federal income tax. For example, if a foreign corporation participates in a confidential corporate tax shelter with a significant purpose of reducing its 10 percent corporate shareholder's Federal income taxes, the temporary regulations would require the shareholder to register the tax shelter if all promoters are foreign.

[40] For purposes of the registration requirements under section 6111(d)(3), it is presumed that the tax shelter promoters may receive fees in excess of $100,000 in the aggregate unless the person who would be responsible for registering the tax shelter can show otherwise.

VII. Investor List Requirement of Section 6112

[41] Any person who organizes or sells an interest in a confidential corporate tax shelter must maintain a list of persons who were sold an interest in the tax shelter and such other information as required by section 6112. See section 301.6112-1T. Amendments to the temporary regulations under section 6112 have been published concurrently with the temporary regulations under section 6111(d). Among other things, the amended temporary regulations under section 6112 require lists to be maintained with respect to transactions for which the avoidance or evasion of Federal income tax is considered to be a significant purpose of the structure of the transaction, as determined in these temporary regulations under section 6111(d)(1)(A), whether or not the transactions are offered under conditions of confidentiality.

VIII. Effective Date

[42] The regulations apply to confidential corporate tax shelters in which any interests are offered for sale after February 28, 2000.

Special Analyses

[43] It has been determined that this Treasury decision is not a significant regulatory action as defined in Executive Order 12866. Therefore, a regulatory assessment is not required. It has also been determined that section 553(b) of the Administrative Procedure Act (5 U.S.C. chapter 5) does not apply to these regulations. It is hereby certified that the collection of information in these regulations will not have a significant economic impact on a substantial number of small entities. This certification is based upon the fact that the persons responsible for promoting and registering the transactions described in these regulations are principally large publicly traded corporations, and the burden is not significant as described earlier in the preamble. Therefore, a Regulatory Flexibility Analysis under the Regulatory Flexibility Act (5 U.S.C. chapter 6) is not required. Pursuant to section 7805(f) of the Internal Revenue Code, these temporary regulations will be submitted to the Chief Counsel for Advocacy of the Small Business Administration for comment on their impact on small business.

Drafting Information

[44] The principal authors of these regulations are Mary Beth Collins and Richard Castanon, Office of Chief Counsel (Passthroughs and Special Industries) and Rebecca Rosenberg, Office of Chief Counsel (International). However, other personnel from the IRS and Treasury Department participated in their development.

List of Subjects

26 CFR Part 301

[45] Employment taxes, Estate taxes, Excise taxes, Gift taxes, Income taxes, Penalties, Reporting and recordkeeping requirements.

26 CFR Part 602

[46] Reporting and recordkeeping requirements.

Adoption of Amendments to the Regulations

[47] Accordingly, 26 CFR parts 301 and 602 are amended as follows:

PART 301 -- PROCEDURE AND ADMINISTRATION